5 Key West Seafood Restaurants to Try on Vacation

Located where the Atlantic Ocean meets the Gulf of Mexico, Key West offers a prime destination for seafood lovers. Enjoy freshly caught shrimp, conch, mahi mahi, stone crab, and grouper at our Key West seafood restaurants! Whether you are looking for an upscale eatery for date night or a laidback restaurant the entire family will love, there is a wealth of seafood restaurants near your property with Rent Key West Vacations:

1. Conch Republic Seafood Company

Enjoy fresh seafood at Conch Republic Seafood Company, housed in a historic seaport formerly known as the Singleton Fish House. Today, they are known for their boat-to-table menu featuring fresh snapper, mahi mahi, tuna, shrimp, and clams.

2. Eaton Street Seafood Market

Eaton Street Seafood Market offers some of the freshest locally caught seafood on the island. Pick fresh fish from the market and have it cooked for you on the premises, or bring fish back to your Rent Key West vacation rental to prepare in your kitchen. They also offer a standard menu with delicious options like lobster rolls, fried fish, and grilled lobster tails.

3. Half Shell Raw Bar

Half Shell Raw Bar receives fresh fish daily from its Half Shell Fish Market. It is best known for its raw bar menu, which features oysters, clams, mussels, and shrimp. This laid-back restaurant offers the perfect place to kick back, feast on fresh seafood, sip on tropical drinks, and watch the sunset. 

4. A&B Lobster House

Discover the perfect Key West seafood restaurant for date night at A&B Lobster House. Indulge in fresh seafood dishes like yellowtail snapper meuniere, crab cakes, royal red shrimp fettuccine, and tuna steak. Pair your meal with a bespoke cocktail and enjoy fantastic waterfront views. 

5. The Lobster Shack

If you are looking for a quick and delicious lunch spot, we recommend visiting The Lobster Shack. They are known for their lobster rolls, but they also offer shrimp rolls, lobster bisque, and seasonal seafood salads. 

Book Your Key West Vacation Rental Today!

Plan your getaway with Rent Key West Vacations and discover the best Key West seafood restaurants. Or book an in-home chef and enjoy a delicious seafood meal from the comfort of your Key West vacation rental. Please contact our reservation specialist at 1-800-833-7368 to help you customize your Key West getaway!