Casa Margarita

3 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms Sleeps 8 Key West 1156 sq. ft. Pet Friendly

Casa Margarita is the perfect luxury retreat if you are looking for a peaceful place that also is in the heart of Old Town Key West. This three-bedroom, three-bath home features a large backyard with lush tropical landscaping, a heated pool, and a large h

Primary Bedroom

1 King

Second Bedroom

1 Queen

Third Bedroom

1 King

Living Room

1 Sofa Bed

Casa Margarita is the ideal for outdoor dining, relaxing, and entertaining, with its spacious covered patio, ample seating, and even an outdoor flat-screen TV. Why go inside?

The living area features plenty of seating and a 55-inch LCD wall-mounted TV. The dining room has a table with four chairs. Additional seating is available at the adjacent breakfast bar overlooking the fully-stocked kitchen.

The primary bedroom in the rear of the home has an ensuite bathroom and king bed. The second bedroom has a queen bed and en suite bathroom. The third bedroom also has a king bed. All bedrooms have flat-screen TVs.

No worries about parking here! The house has a private driveway big enough two vehicles in front of the home for your convenience. But with such a desirable location in the historic seaport district, you can walk to many of Key West's restaurants, art galleries, museums, attractions, and nightlife. Casa Margarita is such a great place that you will never want to leave!

The individual making the reservation must be 25 years or older with proper identification and be an occupant of the property. The maximum people allowed in this property is 8. If there are more than 8 people are in your party upon arrival, your party will be asked to leave without compensation. Violation of ANY house rules will result in your party being asked to leave without compensation.

Tourist Attractions

  • Health Beauty Spa
  • Marinas, Boat Rentals & Excursions
  • Museums
  • Key West Aquarium
  • Public Parks & Beaches
  • Key West Historic Seaport
  • Key West Tropical Forest & Tropical Garden
  • Southernmost Point Buoy
  • Dry Tortugas National Park & Fort Jefferson
  • Fort Zachary Taylor State Park & Beach
  • Sunset Celebration at Mallory Square
  • History Tours - Motorized, Walking & Biking
  • The Florida Reef - N. America’s only living coral barrier reef
  • Key West Marine Park stretching from Higgs Beach to South Beach
  • The Key West Butterfly & Nature Conservatory
  • Food Tours
  • Ghost Tours
  • Pub Crawls
  • Your reservation guest portal will provide details

Accommodation Essentials

  • Hair Dryer
  • Hangers
  • Kitchen
  • Shampoo
  • Wireless Internet
  • Body Wash
  • Air Conditioning
  • Bed Linens
  • Cable
  • Towels
  • Hot Water
  • Dryer
  • Parking
  • Iron & Ironing Board
  • Private Entrance
  • Washer

Sports

  • Paddle Boarding
  • Fishing - Surf
  • Hiking
  • Banana Boat Riding & Water Tubing
  • Wind Surfing
  • Ocean Waterpark & Challenge Course
  • Kayaking
  • Kite Boarding
  • Pickleball
  • Tennis
  • Golfing
  • Scuba Diving
  • Skydiving
  • Your reservation guest portal will provide details
  • Cycling
  • DeepSea Fishing
  • Fishing - Backcountry
  • Jet Skiing
  • Para-sailing
  • Fishing - Pier
  • Sailing
  • Snorkeling
  • Swimming

Leisure

  • Dolphin Watching
  • Dining Out
  • Live Theater, Concerts & Entertainment
  • Your reservation guest portal will provide details
  • Paint & Sip Art Classes
  • Bird Watching
  • Boating
  • Eco Tourism
  • Shopping

Local

  • Banks
  • Grocery Stores
  • Fitness Centers
  • Hospital
  • Laundromats

Kitchen

  • Coffee Maker - Drip
  • Dishes & Silverware
  • Microwave
  • Refrigerator
  • Toaster
  • Stove
  • Dishwasher
  • Oven
  • Dining table
  • Blender

Home Safety

  • Fire Extinguisher
  • Smoke Detector

Outdoor

  • Patio or Balcony
  • Grill

Facility

  • Pool

Entertainment

  • Television

Pool

  • Heated Pool
  • Hot Tub
  • Private Pool
LEAVE A REVIEW
July 27, 2026 - Track Survey

by Steve P

Clean, great location and incredible hosts. Would definitely stay there again!

Thank you for the great review! We look forward to your return stay with us!

June 10, 2026 - Track Survey

by Jessica R

Casa Margarita was perfect for our group with three bedrooms and three bathrooms and a spacious outdoor space including the pool. The only thing that could have been improved was if we could have gone straight to the house instead of having the Uber take a detour to go to the office to get our key.

We are happy to hear that Casa Margarita was perfect for your group!  You are right about the spacious outdoor space.  It's rare in Old Town to have so much space and a pool that big!  Key pick up is at our office for security reasons, so we can verify the occupants are the people listed on the rental agreement.  Our office is only 3-5 minutes by car from the house rental.  We recommend guests have thier Uber wait while they check in at our office since it's a very quick process.  Thank you for staying with us and we hope to see you again.

May 17, 2026 - Track Survey

by Jeff H

We love Casa Margarita and have stayed there 3 years. It’s perfect for 3 couples and is in a perfect location to walk almost everywhere. 

Thank you Jeff and friends! We look forward to your 4th stay with us!

April 19, 2026 - Track Survey

by Cathy P

Casa Margarita is located in a convenient place that makes walking in all directions easy and quick. Most downtown attractions are a 5-30 minute walk away. We loved the pool and hottub. Everything appeared in working order. The beds are comfortable. We found the kitchen to be stocked with the essential cooking utensils, plates and glassware to accommodate 6 people.

Thank you for the great review! This house truly does have everything you need for the perfect family vacation! We are so glad you were able to enjoy all the close by attractions as well as the awesome outdoor area the home provides! We hope to have you back again soon!

February 1, 2026 - Track Survey

by Kathleen W

We had a good experience renting from Rent Key West (second rental). The property we rented (Casa Margarita) was older, as are most Key West properties, leading to a number of maintenance issues. Rent Key West responded in a timely manner. The property itself was fabulous. The house had exactly what we needed, was beautifully decorated, and well stocked with household items. The back pool area was a big wow. Beautiful, private, comfortable.

Thank you for your thoughtful review and for choosing Rent Key West again. We truly appreciate your continued trust and are delighted you had another positive experience.

We're so glad Casa Margarita was a great fit and that you enjoyed the décor, amenities, and especially the private pool area. It's one of our favorite features as well!

We also appreciate your understanding regarding the maintenance issues that can occasionally arise in older Key West homes. We're pleased our team was able to respond promptly and assist during your stay.

Thank you again for your kind words. We look forward to welcoming you back again soon!

November 20, 2025 - Track Survey

by Raymond B

Everyone in the office was very friendly and accommodating. The house was my favorite rental so far in Key West. The back patio with the pool and hot tub was the highlight, and the house is in one of the best locations in Key West. Hope to come back next year!

October 5, 2025 - Track Survey

by Adam R

So awesome!

July 18, 2025 - Track Survey

Beautiful home

by Robert N

Beautiful home with plenty of space for six adults. Pool and backyard living space was great! Close to the marina and activities. Short walk to Duval.

June 17, 2025 - Track Survey

Would stay here again

by Diana E

Loved our stay here! Everything was so clean and in working order. I would stay here when we come back! Thank you so much.

June 16, 2025 - Track Survey

The staff were polite and professional

by Robert B

The rental was clean and very well equipped with everything you would need. The staff were polite and professional. We would definitely return to this unit!!

May 4, 2025 - Track Survey

by Jeff H

We love Casa Margarita

April 13, 2025 - Track Survey

by Cheryl S

The house and location for us was perfect. We would recommend adjusting the shower water pressure as it was very low.

December 28, 2024 - Track Survey

by David H

Great spot and home well appointed.

June 16, 2024 - Airbnb

by Ryan

We had an amazing time staying at Casa Margarita! The outdoor space w/pool and covered patio was the perfect setup for our trip of relaxation. Great location for walking places.

April 21, 2024 - Airbnb

by Jesse

Perfect property for three couples on a long getaway weekend to Key West. Great house! Incredible location! Nearly anything and everything imaginable is within walking distance and for as busy at it was during the daytime, it was surprisingly quiet at night. We did rent a golf cart for finding our way around when walking wasn’t an option and we appreciated having off-street parking. The amenities at the house were as good as advertised - the pool and hot tub were especially popular - and we spent most of our down time sitting around the patio table. After 4 days, we’re still debating our favorite places to eat and drink, but there’s no debate about our house choice; Casa Margarita is the clear winner. Highly recommend and we’ll definitely be back!

March 23, 2024 - Airbnb

by Cristina

Beautiful home! We were three couples, each with our own rooms and bathrooms. pool and hot tub were awesome. location was perfect - hear everything but quiet once at home. highly recommend.

September 3, 2023 - Website

Loved it!

Loved it, this was the 3rd time at Casa Margarita, perfect for the whole family.

Thank you.  We look forward to welcoming you back

May 11, 2023 - Website

Property was clean and beautiful....

by anonymous

property was clean and beatiful would recommend it to everybody.

April 25, 2023 - Website

Awesome property 2nd time renting…

by Anonymous

Awesome property, 2nd time renting Casa Margarita and won't be the last. Love the outdoor living space and updated bathrooms. Very private and secure. Family loved it.

Available
Unavailable
Check-In Only
Check-Out Only


November 2026
S M T W T F S
01 02 03 04 05 06 07
08 09 10 11 12 13 14
15 16
$745
17 18 19 20 21
22
$678
23
$828
24 25 26 27 28
$684
29
$646
30
$677
         
December 2026
S M T W T F S
    01 02 03 04 05
$834
06
$737
07
$745
08
$734
09
$885
10 11 12
13 14
$723
15
$707
16
$736
17
$840
18
$906
19
$1096
20 21 22 23
$1222
24
$1244
25
$1410
26
$1742
27 28 29 30 31    
January 2027
S M T W T F S
          01 02
03
$1230
04
$1120
05
$1105
06
$1122
07
$1210
08
$1334
09
10 11 12 13 14 15
$1698
16
$1813
17
$1623
18
$1417
19
$1437
20
$1367
21
$1512
22
$1571
23
$1575
24
$1382
25
$1318
26
$1451
27
$1503
28 29 30
31            
February 2027
S M T W T F S
  01
$1357
02
$1378
03
$1431
04
$1834
05
$1751
06
$1790
07
$1603
08
$1537
09
$1530
10
$1557
11
$1739
12
$1883
13
$2028
14
$1867
15
$1828
16
$1837
17
$1779
18
$1990
19
$2044
20
$2032
21
$1788
22
$1680
23
$1663
24
$1707
25
$1937
26
$1953
27
$1923
28
$1695
           
March 2027
S M T W T F S
  01
$1593
02
$1583
03
$1600
04
$1776
05
$1867
06
$1873
07
$1729
08
$1744
09
$1736
10
$1746
11
$1853
12
$1914
13
$1959
14
$1798
15
$1790
16
$1780
17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26
$1737
27
$1747
28
$1554
29
$1540
30
$1409
31
$1436
     
April 2027
S M T W T F S
        01
$1602
02
$1681
03
$1683
04
$1452
05
$1361
06
$1338
07
$1363
08
$1501
09
$1544
10
$1537
11
$1364
12
$1295
13
$1275
14
$1301
15 16 17
18 19
$1243
20
$1228
21
$1255
22
$1383
23
$1438
24
$1447
25 26 27 28 29
$1549
30
$1802
 
May 2027
S M T W T F S
            01
$1726
02
$1203
03
$1129
04
$1105
05
$1121
06
$1234
07
$1282
08
$1271
09
$1124
10
$1062
11
$1050
12
$1066
13
$1171
14
$1230
15
$1565
16
$1158
17
$1036
18
$1025
19
$1050
20
$1245
21
$1392
22
23 24 25 26 27
$1147
28
$1190
29
$1190
30
$1129
31
$1118
         
June 2027
S M T W T F S
    01
$1105
02
$1041
03
$1222
04
$1365
05
$1373
06
$1110
07
$1017
08
$945
09
$975
10
$1075
11
$1135
12
$1349
13
$1091
14
$1010
15
$1009
16
$1121
17
$1257
18
$1336
19
$1165
20
$1024
21
$965
22
$948
23
$983
24
$1081
25
$1145
26
$1153
27
$1033
28
$997
29
$987
30
$1202
     
July 2027
S M T W T F S
        01
$1183
02
$1188
03
$1230
04
$1191
05
$1095
06
$1027
07
$1041
08
$1146
09
$1150
10
$1140
11
$1012
12
$954
13
$941
14
$968
15
$1084
16
$1146
17
$1171
18
$1050
19
$992
20
$1302
21
$1081
22
$1135
23
$1263
24
$1299
25
$1168
26
$1148
27
$1416
28
$1228
29
$1297
30
$1282
31
$1132
August 2027
S M T W T F S
01
$999
02
$912
03
$899
04
$905
05
$1019
06
$1101
07
$1120
08
$927
09
$839
10
$808
11
$848
12
$923
13
$1012
14
$1141
15
$816
16
$734
17
$727
18
$941
19
$1099
20
$1231
21
$1224
22
$754
23
$684
24
$684
25
$689
26
$800
27
$847
28
$864
29
$736
30
$665
31
$673
       
September 2027
S M T W T F S
      01
$615
02
$745
03
$773
04
$810
05
$743
06
$748
07
$718
08
$595
09
$681
10
$705
11
$726
12
$613
13
$595
14
$595
15
$595
16
$630
17
$690
18
$697
19
$609
20
$595
21
$595
22
$595
23
$643
24
$712
25
$714
26
$643
27
$595
28
$595
29
$595
30
$689
   
October 2027
S M T W T F S
          01
$874
02
$897
03
$816
04
$735
05
$740
06
$787
07
$874
08
$978
09
$1031
10
$906
11
$909
12
$912
13
$836
14
$950
15
$1049
16
$2048
17
$1743
18
$1538
19
$1509
20
$1679
21
$2009
22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29
$2512
30
$2907
31
$1191
           
November 2027
S M T W T F S
  01
$1100
02
$1123
03
$1324
04
$1581
05
$1771
06
$1833
07
$1629
08
$1560
09
$1778
10
$2640
11
$2709
12
$3419
13
$1877
14
$1202
15
$1047
16
$1027
17
$1036
18
$1140
19
$1210
20
$1215
21
$1213
22
$1135
23
$1164
24
$1510
25
$1475
26
$1466
27
$1415
28
$1242
29
$978
30
$963
       

Book Now

Detailed Quote
Add to Favorites
Inquire
Share
Print